Agency vs. in-house recruitment: Which is the right career fit for you?

Many recruiters face the choice between agency and in-house recruiting careers. To help you make the right choice for you, here’s an overview of their similarities and differences and a summary of the qualities you’ll need to succeed in each role:

Similarities between agency and in-house recruiting careers:

  • Both have to be excellent sourcers: Good recruiters know that they need to use multiple sources to attract hard-to-find talent, regardless of where they work. Both agency and corporate recruiters engage in proactive sourcing, aiming to build talent pipelines and fill vacancies quickly.

Whether you work for an agency or in-house, sourcing is a powerful tool. Download our complete sourcing guide for free.

  • Both have to be familiar with the best HR tools: Technology helps streamline the recruitment process. Recruiters use project management and email tools for their administrative duties, Applicant Tracking Systems and resume databases to manage candidates and online platforms to source their next hires.
  • Both have to be excellent relationship builders: The key to being a successful recruiter is developing strong, long-term relationships. Good recruiters build these relationships by developing strong interpersonal skills, sending personalized messages and always following up with people.

The main differences between agency and in-house recruiting:

Scope of responsibilities:

Agency recruitment and in-house recruitment: responsibilities

Qualities and skills:

agency in-house recruitment: skills

Salary and bonus options:

Agency recruitment and in-house recruitment: salary

Branding:

Agency recruitment and in-house recruitment: branding

Career development:

Agency recruitment and in-house recruitment: career

How to move from a staffing agency to a corporate recruiting role (and vice versa)

Agency and in-house recruiting may seem worlds apart. But, switching from one role to the other could be a smart move for your career, once you find what kind of work environment fits you best.

Panos Zervas, the Recruitment, Training and Development Manager at Bioiatriki SA shares some insights from his previous experience as a staffing recruiter.

You should be prepared to adapt to a different way of working. Also, think of what kind of environment will showcase your skills.

Though many of your daily duties might be similar, you should expect to face new challenges:

Agency recruitment and in-house recruitment: challenges

When deciding which path to choose, you should consider the main differences between staffing and corporate recruiters and determine which option best suits your personality and career goals. Whichever career path you choose, you need the same basic qualities to be a successful recruiter. You need to be able to understand people and develop long-term relationships.

Considering hiring a recruiting agency? See our tutorial on when to hire a recruiting agency.

Looking for an all-in-one recruiting solution? Workable can improve candidate sourcing, interviewing and applicant tracking for a streamlined hiring process. Sign up for our 15-day free trial today.

Get a free trial

Christina Pavlou

Christina is a writer at Workable, previously a recruiter. She writes about diversity in the workplace and reports on the shape of things to come. She tweets @ChristinaPaulou.

Latest in this category

How to be a successful recruiter: Advice for each hiring stage

Screen, interview, hire and repeat. That could be the shortest job description for a recru...

Important HR skills to master

The most important HR skills and how to master them

Whether you’re kickstarting your career in Human Resources, or you’re a seasoned HR profes...

The most important skills recruiters need and how to cultivate them

Beyond writing good job descriptions, evaluating candidates and sourcing potential hires, ...