Need to start saving with a new ATS? Learn how to calculate the return on investment of your ATS Calculate ROI now

The art of building a stellar startup team from scratch

As someone who's navigated the highs and lows of the startup world, I understand the monumental impact a strong team can have on a company's trajectory. The right blend of talent, mindset, and values goes beyond being a support structure — it's the engine of innovation and growth.

Chris Allen

Chris Allen

Senior Vice President of Marketing at Heartland

building a stellar startup team

My name is Chris Allen, and I am the Senior Vice President of Marketing at Heartland, a people-centric fintech company serving over 1 Million entrepreneurs today. I have over 15 years of executive leadership experience in marketing for B2B tech and SaaS companies, and I specialize in revenue marketing powered by content in highly matrixed organizations.

In this piece, I’ll discuss the role of a well-built team in startup success. From the early days of a fledgling venture to navigating major corporate milestones, the right team is not just a part of the journey — it is the journey.

1. Understand the challenges of building a startup team

One of the most pressing challenges in building a startup team is maneuvering through the constraint of limited resources. Unlike established companies, when you’re just starting up a new business, you often operate with tight budgets and scarce manpower, making every hiring decision crucial. 

This requires a strategic approach to resource allocation, where maximizing the potential of each team member becomes essential — the key is not just finding the right talent but also ensuring that each hire can wear multiple hats, contributing diversely to the startup’s growth and adaptability. 

Vince Lombardo, the president of Heartland, highlights the intricate challenges involved in assembling and managing a startup team. Unlike established corporations, startups often operate with limited resources, including tight budgets and minimal manpower. 

This scarcity makes every hiring decision pivotal. 

While building the team, he learned the importance of strategic resource allocation and the necessity of maximizing the potential of each team member. The key isn’t just finding the right talent but ensuring each hire can contribute in multiple ways, thereby supporting the startup’s growth and adaptability.

For startups, it’s crucial to not only hire for skills but also for cultural fit. Aligning team members with the company’s core values is as important as their professional abilities. 

The insights from Lombardo’s experience reflect a deep understanding of the nuanced dynamics of team building in a startup environment, where resource constraints necessitate a multifaceted approach to hiring and team development.

2. Decide on core values

Core values are the heartbeat of a startup’s culture, directly influencing the essence of its workplace environment. They serve as a guiding light for hiring decisions and ensure that each new team member brings the necessary skills and aligns with the company’s ethos. 

When startups establish clear core values, they create a cohesive culture where every employee aligns with the shared principles.

Katharine Wolf’s journey in founding Odetta exemplifies the impact of aligning business objectives with personal values. She founded Odetta with a mission to empower highly educated women in regions where they face significant barriers in the job market, particularly in the Middle East and South Asia. 

These barriers may stem from societal norms, logistical challenges, or workplace cultures that restrict women’s participation in the traditional workforce.  

Katharine’s mission is to connect these skilled women to global gig economy opportunities, thereby offering them remote, flexible work that overcomes the limitations they face locally. It’s rooted in addressing gender disparities observed from a young age, and demonstrates how a strong, value-driven foundation is critical for a startup’s success.

Her venture not only addresses a market need but also champions a cause, making Odetta a purpose-driven enterprise.

3. Adopt the right hiring mindset

Adopting the right mindset in hiring is pivotal for the growth and sustainability of a startup. Emphasizing diversity brings a lot of different perspectives and ideas and fosters innovation and creativity. Equally important is seeking adaptability in candidates: working in a startup demands individuals who can pivot and evolve with the company’s needs. 

Alignment with the company’s vision ensures that each team member is not just a cog in the machine, but a passionate contributor to the collective dream, driving the startup towards its long-term goals with shared enthusiasm and commitment.

The expansion of Bondi Bowls illustrates the importance of a mindful hiring approach. Bailey Wilson, the founder, faced the challenge of rapidly building a team for her burgeoning business. 

Her strategy focused on identifying individuals who resonated with her passion for health and community engagement, and who could adapt to the dynamic nature of a growing startup. Bailey’s approach was about finding the right people who could embrace and contribute to Bondi Bowls’ ethos. 

This aligns seamlessly with the startup hiring mindset, emphasizing adaptability, shared vision, and a commitment to the company’s core values. As a result, Bondi Bowls didn’t just grow in size but also in its capacity to impact communities positively.

4. Develop an effective onboarding process

This step is vital for building a strong foundation for team dynamics, encouraging open communication, and aligning individual goals with the company’s vision. A strategic onboarding process ensures that new team members feel welcomed and understood, fostering a sense of belonging from day one. 

Tim Tebow is a renowned athlete and philanthropist. His approach at the Tim Tebow Foundation is characterized by setting a vivid end goal and inspiring his team to see beyond the immediate challenges. Tebow advocates for focusing on the ultimate objective, emphasizing that hard work is not the goal itself, but a means to achieve the end result.

Tebow believes in being hands-on, showing rather than just telling. This approach gains respect and fosters a sense of camaraderie. He exemplifies this by participating in tasks alongside his team, rather than delegating difficult tasks to newcomers.

Tebow’s philosophy centers around painting a clear picture of success, not just in terms of hard work but in visualizing the rewards of that effort. He encourages envisioning the end result — whether it’s a football player dreaming of triumph in a stadium or a team member visualizing the success of a project. 

This vision, Tebow argues, is more motivating than the abstract concept of hard work.

This approach reflects a deep understanding of human motivation and team dynamics. He shows that by inspiring with a clear end goal, teams can cultivate discipline, resilience, and a collective effort towards a common objective. This philosophy applies not only in sports but also in business and life, where the clarity of the ultimate goal can transform the way teams work and achieve success.

5. Foster a culture of growth and development

Cultivating a growth and development culture is all about nurturing a workspace where learning and professional growth are not just encouraged, but are a key part of the daily routine. It’s about moving beyond the traditional approach to development and creating an environment where every team member has the chance to learn, improve, and excel. 

This means rolling out things like mentorship programs, hands-on training sessions, and providing plenty of resources for self-guided learning. The aim is to create a vibrant, supportive workplace where growth is ingrained in the culture and where everyone, regardless of their role, feels they have the support and opportunities to continuously develop their skills and advance in their careers.

Christina Tosi’s journey with Milk Bar is a stellar example of cultivating a culture of growth and development in an entrepreneurial environment. Her approach to business combines extraordinary discipline and boundless creativity, mirrored in her philosophy of “just bake the cake.” 

This attitude encapsulates the essence of learning traditional business rules only to artfully subvert them. Tosi’s example highlights the importance of embracing new experiences and prioritizing flexibility, while nurturing one’s creativity and adapting amidst uncertainty. 

She is focused on understanding and connecting with customers — which coupled with a focus on streamlined operations underlines the vital role of creating a suitable culture for business success. 

Tosi’s journey with Milk Bar, characterized by innovative thinking and a relentless pursuit of growth, is an inspiring blueprint for fostering a culture of continuous learning and development in any entrepreneurial venture.

Related: The Startup Hiring Guide: Hiring for rapid growth from 5 to 50

Build your startup dream team

We’ve navigated various facets of constructing a startup dream team. As we wrap up, it’s crucial to reiterate the undeniable significance of a well-constructed team in startup success.

A team isn’t just a group of individuals working under the same banner — it’s a mosaic of diverse talents, perspectives, and aspirations, all converging towards a singular vision. 

Remember, in the often unpredictable world of startups, your team is your strongest asset. It’s the resilience in times of uncertainty, the creative spark in moments of challenge, and the relentless drive that propels your vision forward. 

As a leader, your role extends beyond mere recruitment to nurturing, inspiring, and leading by example. Let your team be the embodiment of your startup’s values, aspirations, and dreams. The path to success is paved with challenges, but with the right team, no hurdle is insurmountable. 

Frequently asked questions

Still spending too much time hiring the right candidates?

Try our best-in-class ATS software. We make it easy to source, evaluate and hire best-fit candidates – and quickly, too.

Make hiring easy

Let's grow together

Explore our full platform with a 15-day free trial.
Post jobs, get candidates and onboard employees all in one place.

Start a free trial