Just released: Workable’s AI Recruiting Agent Check it out

Stop Trying to Hack the Hiring Process. Here’s What Actually Works.

According to the internet, the secret to landing a job is to trick the applicant tracking system, stuff your résumé with the right keywords, and tell interviewers you signed an NDA if you don’t want to discuss your previous employer.

There’s just one problem: Much of that advice falls apart when you talk to someone who has actually done the hiring.

 

 

Enter Mike Peditto, the recruiter and content creator behind Realistic Recruiting, who has built an audience by pulling back the curtain on how hiring actually works.

His path to becoming a recruiting voice was unconventional. After spending years in talent acquisition, a layoff prompted him to start making TikToks about his job search. When his next job ended just six weeks later, he documented his search publicly, sharing interviews, résumé reviews, and the realities of being a candidate.

The content took off, and Peditto found himself in an unusual position: someone who understood the frustrations of job seekers and the decisions being made on the other side of the interview table.

At HR Tech in Las Vegas, Workable’s Brendan Jeannetti sat down with Mike for a live episode of Next at Work, the podcast from Workable, to discuss the advice candidates should stop following, the hiring practices employers need to reconsider, and where AI genuinely belongs in recruiting.

He had plenty to say.

1. Please stop trying to hack the ATS.

There’s an entire corner of the career-advice internet dedicated to finding secret ways around the hiring process.

Some people recommend hiding instructions in résumés to manipulate AI screening tools. Others suggest inventing credentials, creating fake companies, or claiming that a nondisclosure agreement prevents them from discussing their employment history.

Peditto has little patience for any of it.

He’s even gone as far as running a background check on himself, mixing fabricated jobs and degrees with legitimate ones, to demonstrate how employment verification actually works.

He also pushes back against the persistent belief that applicants need to match every keyword in a job description to get noticed.

Modern AI-powered recruiting technology is considerably more sophisticated than the keyword filters often portrayed in viral career advice. AI-assisted screening can recognize relevant experience through context, rather than relying exclusively on exact word matches.

A candidate who writes that they “led” a team isn’t necessarily at a disadvantage because the job description uses the word “managed.”

And while no hiring process is perfect, Peditto argues that candidates are often being sold imaginary shortcuts to problems that don’t have easy solutions.

His message is straightforward: Spend less time trying to outsmart the technology and more time demonstrating why you’re qualified.

 

2. Yes, you can use AI to write your résumé. Just don’t make it terrible.

Few job-search debates generate as much anxiety as the question of whether employers can tell when applicants have used AI.

Peditto’s response was refreshingly direct.

“You didn’t get rejected because you used AI. You got rejected and you used AI, and that’s different.”

His argument is that using AI isn’t inherently a problem. Submitting generic, poorly written material that doesn’t communicate your experience is.

If 200 candidates use the same prompts to generate nearly identical résumés, the result is a mountain of forgettable applications. But that’s a quality problem, not necessarily an AI problem.

The distinction matters because employers are increasingly interested in candidates who understand how to use AI effectively.

Peditto points out the contradiction in criticizing applicants for using tools that companies actively want their employees to master.

Of course, using AI well requires some actual work. Candidates still need to provide context, refine the output, verify the information, and make sure the final document accurately reflects their experience.

An AI-generated résumé shouldn’t read like it could belong to anyone.

And if you’re applying to a company that values AI fluency, submitting something obviously generic might demonstrate the exact opposite of the skill you’re hoping to showcase.

 

3. Leaving a toxic job? Your interview isn’t the place to roast your boss.

When I asked Mike how candidates should explain leaving a toxic workplace, his initial answer was one word:

“Lie.”

Naturally, that requires some explanation.

Peditto isn’t suggesting candidates fabricate credentials or invent employment histories. His advice is to resist turning the interview into a detailed account of everything wrong with their current employer.

Even if every complaint is justified, the interviewer doesn’t know your boss. They only know you, and their first impression may be shaped by how you talk about someone they’ve never met.

Instead, Peditto recommends focusing on what attracted you to the opportunity in front of you.

Explain what interests you about the role, what you’re looking for in your next move, and why this particular position might make sense.

I could relate to this personally. Having dealt with a difficult boss earlier in my career, I found that explaining what I wanted from my next opportunity was far more productive than explaining everything I wanted to escape.

Peditto also encourages candidates to approach interviews as a two-way evaluation rather than an audition where the employer holds all the power.

“The right manager isn’t scared off by having to convince you this is a good job.”

It’s an important distinction, particularly for people trying to escape unhealthy workplaces.

Getting an offer is one thing. Finding a manager and environment that won’t recreate the same problems is another.

Peditto acknowledges that his advice is aimed primarily at people seeking the right long-term opportunity, rather than those who urgently need any available job. But his broader point holds: Candidates should be evaluating employers just as employers evaluate them.

 

 

4. What if salary negotiation shouldn’t exist at all?

Here’s an opinion that might make a few hiring managers uncomfortable.

Peditto thinks we’d be better off eliminating salary negotiation entirely.

His ideal hiring process involves an employer determining exactly what a position is worth, publishing that compensation, and paying whoever gets hired the stated amount.

No guessing games. No awkward negotiations. No wondering whether someone else landed a higher salary simply because they were more comfortable asking for one.

The argument is rooted in pay equity.

Traditional salary negotiations can reward confidence and negotiating experience rather than job-related qualifications. Peditto believes standardized compensation would help reduce those inconsistencies, particularly for groups that have historically faced disadvantages in salary negotiations.

Of course, that’s not how most companies operate today.

So his practical advice for candidates is to discuss compensation as early as possible.

If you need $120,000 to consider leaving your current position and the company cannot exceed $100,000, discovering that incompatibility after four interviews and a take-home assessment benefits absolutely nobody.

But what happens when a job posting lists a salary range of $100,000 to $120,000? Is $120,000 really the ceiling?

According to Peditto, it depends.

Some employers publish ranges that leave room for negotiation. Others establish firm compensation bands and stick to them. His recommendation is to ask about flexibility rather than assume that every posted range works the same way.

He also challenges the assumption that employers who refuse to negotiate are automatically being unreasonable.

If a company publishes its maximum compensation and offers that amount upfront, is it really being inflexible? Or is it simply skipping the game?

It’s a worthwhile question for HR leaders, especially as salary transparency becomes a more prominent part of hiring conversations.

 

 

5. AI is making recruiters more effective. But automation still needs judgment.

You can’t spend a day at HR Tech without hearing about AI.

And for good reason. Advances in recruiting technology are creating opportunities to automate repetitive tasks, evaluate candidate qualifications more efficiently, and give recruiting teams more time to focus on higher-value work.

But after walking the conference floor and discussing the latest innovations, Peditto offered a useful reality check.

Not every task becomes more efficient just because AI can technically perform it.

Consider the employee who gets asked for a concise report, feeds the request into an AI tool, and sends their manager an unedited, 30-page document.

The employee might have saved time. Their manager now has 30 pages to sift through.

That’s not necessarily productivity. It’s moving the work to somebody else.

Peditto sees significant potential for AI in recruiting, particularly when it comes to repetitive, time-consuming activities like initial résumé screening.

He points out that experienced recruiters can often assess basic qualifications remarkably quickly. In one demonstration shared with his audience, Peditto timed himself reviewing ten fictional résumés and averaged just 6.87 seconds per document.

It wasn’t a scientific experiment, but it illustrated how quickly an experienced recruiter can identify relevant information.

His point wasn’t that recruiters are infallible. Quite the opposite.

Human recruiters overlook qualified candidates, advance people who turn out to be poor fits, and make imperfect judgments all the time.

Peditto believes AI can perform certain screening activities just as effectively as a human recruiter, potentially at much greater speed and scale.

That creates an opportunity to spend less time on initial administrative work and more time on the conversations and decisions that actually benefit from human expertise.

But he draws a firmer line around relationship-building, offer negotiations, and decisions requiring discernment.

His standard for deciding whether to automate something is simple:

Is the AI-generated result as good as the work a capable human would produce?

If the answer is no, the technology might not be the right solution for that particular task.

For recruiting leaders, that’s a more useful question than simply asking how much of the hiring process can be automated.

 

 

 

The bigger question: What should recruiters actually be doing?

Beyond the individual career tips, our conversation kept returning to a larger question facing the recruiting profession.

As AI becomes more capable of handling sourcing, screening, and administrative work, where should recruiters focus their expertise?

Peditto believes the profession needs to move further into workforce planning, compensation strategy, and the business decisions that shape hiring in the first place.

If a recruiter’s entire contribution is sourcing candidates, reviewing résumés, conducting interviews, and moving applicants through a process, more of that work will become vulnerable to automation.

But understanding what an organization needs, advising leaders, building relationships, and exercising informed judgment are different responsibilities.

And those responsibilities require organizations to give recruiting teams a meaningful seat at the table.

The opportunity is significant. With AI taking on more repetitive work, recruiters can become more strategic partners to the businesses they support.

There’s also a lesson here for candidates.

Technology is changing how people find jobs and how companies identify talent. But the fundamentals Peditto keeps returning to are surprisingly familiar: communicate your experience clearly, ask good questions, understand your value, and don’t waste time trying to game a process you don’t fully understand.

Let's grow together

Explore our full platform with a 15-day free trial.
Post jobs, get candidates and onboard employees all in one place.