Win one of three $100 Amazon gift cards! Take our new survey on DEI: START NOW

Payroll Manager interview questions and answers

Use these sample Payroll Manager interview questions to identify qualified candidates for your open roles. Feel free to add any specific questions that meet your needs.

Christina Pavlou
Christina Pavlou

An experienced recruiter and HR professional who has transferred her expertise to insightful content to support others in HR.

Payroll Manager interview questions

Make sure that you are interviewing the best payroll managers. Sign up for Workable’s 15-day free trial to hire better, faster.

10 good payroll manager interview questions

  1. If you received complaints from employees about errors in this month’s payroll, what would be the first thing you do?
  2. You realized that you made a mistake in the payroll and as a result one employee was underpaid. How would you address the issue?
  3. How would you create a report that forecasts next year’s payroll expenses?
  4. An employee claims that a coworker in the same position has a higher salary and demands an explanation from you. How would you reply?
  5. What guidelines would you write to explain the payroll process to your team?
  6. You realize there’s a stark gender pay gap in a specific department within the company. Would you leave it be, or bring the issue up to HR?
  7. What payroll software do you use?
  8. Are you familiar with HRIS systems? If so, which ones?
  9. How do you check your work for accuracy before submitting payroll?
  10. According to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), what’s the overtime pay rate for nonexempt employees?

Here are 10 essential interview questions and sample answers to help identify the best candidates for this role.

1. If you received complaints from employees about errors in this month’s payroll, what would be the first thing you do?

This question assesses the candidate’s problem-solving and communication skills.

Sample answer:

“I would first verify the complaints to see if the errors are genuine. If confirmed, I would immediately communicate with the affected employees to assure them that the issue is being addressed.”

2. You realized that you made a mistake in the payroll and as a result one employee was underpaid. How would you address the issue?

This question evaluates the candidate’s ethical considerations and problem-solving abilities.

Sample answer:

“I would immediately inform the affected employee and rectify the mistake as soon as possible, rather than waiting for the next payroll cycle. Transparency and speed are crucial in such situations.”

3. How would you create a report that forecasts next year’s payroll expenses?

This question tests the candidate’s analytical and planning skills.

Sample answer:

“I would analyze the current year’s payroll data, consider any planned organizational changes, and use predictive analytics tools to forecast next year’s payroll expenses.”

4. An employee claims that a coworker in the same position has a higher salary and demands an explanation from you. How would you reply?

This question assesses the candidate’s communication and conflict-resolution skills.

Sample answer:

“I would review the salary structures to ensure they are in line with company policy and then have a confidential discussion with the employee to address their concerns.”

5. What guidelines would you write to explain the payroll process to your team?

This question evaluates the candidate’s ability to communicate complex processes in an understandable manner.

Sample answer:

“I would create a step-by-step guide that outlines each phase of the payroll process, from data collection to final disbursement, including timelines and responsibilities.”

6. You realize there’s a stark gender pay gap in a specific department within the company. Would you leave it be, or bring the issue up to HR?

This question tests the candidate’s ethical considerations and sense of responsibility.

Sample answer:

“I would definitely bring it up with HR and provide them with the data to substantiate the claim. Ignoring such an issue is not an option.”

7. What payroll software do you use?

This question assesses the candidate’s familiarity with tools commonly used in payroll management.

Sample answer:

“I have experience with ADP, Paychex, and QuickBooks Payroll.”

8. Are you familiar with HRIS systems? If so, which ones?

This question gauges the candidate’s knowledge of integrated systems that combine HR and payroll functions.

Sample answer:

“Yes, I am familiar with Workday and BambooHR.”

9. How do you check your work for accuracy before submitting payroll?

Thi s question evaluates the candidate’s attention to detail and commitment to accuracy.

Sample answer:

“I double-check all entries and run a ‘test payroll’ first. I also cross-reference with timekeeping systems and departmental records.”

10. According to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), what’s the overtime pay rate for nonexempt employees?

This question tests the candidate’s knowledge of labor laws relevant to payroll.

Sample answer:

“According to the FLSA, the overtime pay rate for nonexempt employees is one and a half times their regular rate of pay.”

What does a good payroll manager candidate look like?

A strong Payroll Manager candidate should have a deep understanding of payroll systems, labor laws, and tax regulations. They should also possess excellent analytical, communication, and problem-solving skills.



Payroll Manager Interview Questions

Payroll Managers ensure employees are paid accurately and on time. They also manage insurance coverages, tax deductions and bonuses. Their academic background typically includes a Human Resources and/or Accounting degree.

Candidates for this role should have experience issuing payrolls for a workforce similar to your company’s. Keep an eye out for professionals who have worked in your industry as payroll managers or payroll officers, as they’ll be more familiar with specific requirements and regulations. Familiarity with your payroll software is a plus, but put most of your focus on how they organize employee records and check their work for accuracy.

Payroll Managers handle sensitive information with confidentiality and remain calm under stressful situations. Look for detail-oriented candidates you can count on to stay up-to-date with labor law changes. If the role includes managing a team, test candidates’ leadership skills.

Let’s summarize some of the questions and add a few more divided into specific types.

Operational and Situational questions

  • If you received complaints from employees about errors in this month’s payroll, what would be the first thing you do?
  • You realized that you made a mistake in the payroll and as a result one employee was underpaid. How would you address the issue? Is it better to compensate the difference as soon as possible or add it to next month’s payroll? Why?
  • How would you create a report that forecasts next year’s payroll expenses?
  • An employee claims that a coworker in the same position has a higher salary and demands an explanation from you. How would you reply?
  • What guidelines would you write to explain the payroll process to your team?
  • You realize there’s a stark gender pay gap in a specific department within the company. Would you leave it be, or bring the issue up to HR? Why or why not?

Role-specific questions

  • What payroll software do you use?
  • Are you familiar with HRIS systems? If so, which ones?
  • How do you check your work for accuracy before submitting payroll?
  • What’s the best timekeeping method for employees who work in shifts?
  • What’s included in local taxes withholdings?
  • According to the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), what’s the overtime pay rate for nonexempt employees?

Behavioral questions

  • How do you deal with deadlines? Tell me about a time you successfully managed a stressful situation.
  • What resources do you use to learn about new labor regulations?
  • Have you ever suggested and implemented a change that helped streamline the payroll process? If so, what was it?
  • How do you explain financial and insurance details to employees in simple terms?

Frequently asked questions

Ready to fine-tune this interview kit?
Regenerate with AI

Jump to section

    Let's grow together

    Explore our full platform with a 15-day free trial.
    Post jobs, get candidates and onboard employees all in one place.

    Start a free trial