Win one of three $100 Amazon gift cards! Take our new survey on DEI: START NOW

Payroll Specialist interview questions and answers

These Payroll Specialist interview questions can assist you in designing an effective interview process. Look for those questions that will help you find what you are looking for in candidates.

Nikoletta Bika
Nikoletta Bika

Nikoletta holds an MSc in HR management and has written extensively about all things HR and recruiting.

payroll specialist interview questions

Make sure that you are interviewing the best payroll specialists. Sign up for Workable’s 15-day free trial to hire better, faster.

10 good payroll specialist interview questions

  1. How do you ensure attendance records are reported on time?
  2. If two clients came to your office to complain at the same time, how would you handle it?
  3. An employee tells you that they received less money than agreed. How do you go about investigating this?
  4. What would be your first week’s priorities if we hired you?
  5. If an employee insisted that you tell them the salary of a coworker, how would you respond?
  6. What kind of reports should a payroll specialist prepare?
  7. How familiar are you with FLSA?
  8. How do you follow changes regarding IRS regulations?
  9. What’s included in local taxes withholdings?
  10. What are the payroll source documents you need?

Here are 10 essential interview questions and sample answers to help identify the best candidates for this role.

1. How do you ensure attendance records are reported on time?

This question aims to understand the candidate’s organizational skills and attention to detail.

Sample answer:

“I set reminders and use payroll software that allows for real-time updates. I also coordinate with HR to ensure all records are accurate and submitted on time.”

2. If two clients came to your office to complain at the same time, how would you handle it?

This question assesses the candidate’s ability to manage stressful situations and prioritize tasks.

Sample answer:

“I would calmly acknowledge both clients and ask one to wait while I quickly address the other’s concern. I’d then follow up to ensure both issues are resolved.”

3. An employee tells you that they received less money than agreed. How do you go about investigating this?

This question gauges the candidate’s problem-solving skills and understanding of payroll processes.

Sample answer:

“I would first verify the employee’s claim by checking the payroll records and employment contract. If an error is found, I’d correct it immediately and ensure it doesn’t happen again.”

4. What would be your first week’s priorities if we hired you?

This question aims to understand the candidate’s onboarding process and how they would prioritize tasks.

Sample answer:

“My first week would involve understanding the existing payroll system, meeting the team, and reviewing any pending payroll issues that need immediate attention.”

5. If an employee insisted that you tell them the salary of a coworker, how would you respond?

This question assesses the candidate’s understanding of confidentiality and ethical considerations in payroll.

Sample answer:

“I would politely inform the employee that I cannot disclose confidential information about another employee’s salary.”

6. What kind of reports should a payroll specialist prepare?

This question aims to gauge the candidate’s understanding of the reporting requirements in payroll.

Sample answer:

“Regular reports should include payroll summaries, tax reports, and overtime tracking. These help in both financial planning and compliance.”

7. How familiar are you with FLSA?

This question assesses the candidate’s knowledge of labor laws relevant to payroll.

Sample answer:

“I am well-versed in FLSA guidelines, particularly concerning overtime pay, minimum wage, and child labor laws.”

8. How do you follow changes regarding IRS regulations?

This question aims to understand how the candidate stays updated with tax laws and regulations.

Sample answer:

“I subscribe to IRS newsletters and regularly attend webinars and training to stay updated on any changes in regulations.”

9. What’s included in local taxes withholdings?

This question gauges the candidate’s understanding of tax withholdings at the local level.

Sample answer:

“Local tax withholdings can include city and county taxes, school district taxes, and other local service taxes.”

10. What are the payroll source documents you need?

This question aims to assess the candidate’s understanding of the documentation required for payroll processing.

Sample answer:

“I would need timesheets, attendance records, tax forms like W-4s, and any other documents related to benefits and deductions.”

What does a good payroll specialist candidate look like?

A strong payroll specialist candidate will have a solid understanding of payroll processes, tax laws, and labor regulations. They should also possess excellent organizational and communication skills.



Payroll Specialist Interview Questions

Payroll specialists (or payroll clerks) can be found in-house or in consultancy firms where other companies outsource their payroll. Accounting/payroll experience is preferred most of the time. A background in customer service can be useful, whether they have to deal with internal or external clients.

Every payroll specialist should be good with numbers. They can’t succeed without a strong attention to detail, organizational ability, communication skills and commitment to confidentiality. Things get hectic around payroll time, so managing stress is very important. You can ask the following behavioral and situational questions to assess those traits.

If you don’t have time to train new hires, be on the lookout for candidates who have the kind of expertise needed in your business. For example, payroll specialists who work with public organizations may need more diverse knowledge of procedures or legislation (e.g. 403(b) plans). Others may need experience in a similar sized business or a unionized environment.

Let’s summarize some of the questions and add a few more to assist you further.

Operational and Situational questions

  • How do you ensure attendance records are reported on time?
  • If two clients came to your office to complain at the same time, how would you handle it?
  • An employee tells you that they received less money that agreed. How do you go about investigating this?
  • What would be your first week’s priorities if we hired you?
  • If an employee insisted that you tell them the salary of a coworker, how would you respond?

Role-specific questions

  • What kind of reports should a payroll specialist prepare?
  • How familiar are you with FLSA?
  • How do you follow changes regarding IRS regulations?
  • What’s included in local taxes withholdings?
  • What are the payroll source documents you need?
  • What’s your experience with union contracts?
  • Are you familiar with Kronos? What other software do you use in your job?
  • How do you maintain attention to detail when entering employee data?

Behavioral questions

  • Give me an example of a time you improved a payroll process
  • Recall a time you found it difficult to collaborate with a colleague. How did you handle it?
  • Tell me about a time you were stressed on the job. What did you do?
  • Was there a time you didn’t manage to provide excellent customer service? What should you had done differently?
  • Tell me about a time you had to deliver negative news to a client

Frequently asked questions

Ready to fine-tune this interview kit?
Regenerate with AI

Jump to section

    Let's grow together

    Explore our full platform with a 15-day free trial.
    Post jobs, get candidates and onboard employees all in one place.

    Start a free trial